On Sunday, 25 October 2026, I attended a relaunch of the book African Roots of Jamaican Culture. The book is the late Prof. Mervyn C. Alleyne's classic, first published in the UK in 1998. Ian Randle Publishers felt the need to reissue this publication because of its ongoing relevance to Jamaican society, and on hand to host was the African Caribbean Institute of Jamaica/Jamaica Memory Bank, a division within the Ministry of Culture, Gender, Entertainment and Sports. It was an occasion where the culture of the majority of Jamaicans was acknowledged as the core of who we are as a nation.
 |
| Image Source: Instagram, Ian Randle Publishers |
Yet, there are moments in the life of the nation when the centrality of that culture of the majority is called into question. Since 28 October 2026, the response of the Jamaican Prime Minister to some statements by dancehall artist Beenie Man has stirred some emotions and has generated several debates within the Jamaican community. Having listened to some of what has been said, I will share here some thoughts that I hope can improve the quality of Jamaica’s democracy and Jamaican lives.
Harvard historian Sven Beckert, in his 2025 book Capitalism: A Global History, makes the point that capitalism as we know it began to fully experience its power in the Caribbean. In the context of this history, the Caribbean and Jamaica are not marginal to global capitalism. We were born in it and have been foundational to its roots and to its shaping with significant people-led movements such as the 1760 Tacky emancipation war, the 1791-1804 Haitian revolution, and the 1831 Sam Sharpe uprising, among others that shaped modern capitalism, and with it modern notions of sovereignty and freedom.
Given this global connectedness, the political trends we see globally in the US, South America, Europe, and other parts of the world are not trends that we should ignore in the Caribbean and Jamaica, because our modern states have never existed outside of these global trends.
Jamaica has a very storied history of challenging the status quo shaped by the forces of capitalism birthed on the Caribbean shores. That tradition began with the Maroons, through Chief Tacky, Sam Sharpe, Paul Bogle, and other resistance movements, into the rise of Alexander Bedward, Marcus Garvey, Leonard Howell, and the rise of the Rastafari, into the labor protest movements all the way up to the 1970s, and for which Jamaican music became, in the later years, a quintessential expression of this rich Jamaican history and who we are as a people. This is the throughline and history that has marked us, and in modern business parlance, branded Jamaica as a nation of resistance and a people who are staunch defenders of justice, truth and rights, an imagery that is virtually inseparable from the global pan-African struggle for human dignity, and the sovereignty and freedom I named above. This history is the reason why it was the Rastafarian Bob Marley’s music that was the soundtrack to the Zimbabwe liberation struggles, the South African Anti-Apartheid struggles, and the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989. It remains the reason why he was awarded a UN Peace Medal of the Third World in 1978, and why, up to now, Bob Marley is one of the 20th century’s most important and influential entertainment icons, and why, according to Forbes, the estate of a Jamaican musician, dead since 1981, still earns close to US$20M annually. This is the halo of the brand under which Jamaica lives globally – sovereignty, freedom and democracy. Forged from the experience of formerly enslaved people.
Perception, as it turns out, is its own reality, because whereas in the global popular imagination Jamaica may be teeming with Rastafari brethren and sistren, speaking the Iyaric language of the community, and practicing an ital livity, the Rastafari may formally account for just above one percent of the Jamaican population, yet the Rastafari iconography permeates all areas of the Jamaican cultural fabric, both formally and informally. Per the American Marketing Association, if their definition of a brand is of any significance, “a brand is any distinctive feature like a name, term, design, or symbol that identifies goods or services,” which would include goods, services, ideas, or experiences that are popularly associated with Jamaica and Jamaicans; then none of the foregoing can be dismissed as a significant part of what is brand Jamaica.
Further, the contributions of Jamaica’s athletes and our sporting culture have earned us a more than outsized space in the global entertainment and sports imagination. All of which so far has been tied to the activities of the culture from below, that is, the culture of the ordinary Jamaican people. Jamaica’s ‘high’ culture has consistently been opposed to the culture that has emerged from these lowly spaces, and it is often described and treated with derision until it can no longer be ignored. How dare a ‘boy’ from the ghetto speak politics? It is not his place to do so.
Globally renowned academics of Jamaican heritage, such as Stuart Hall and Rex Nettleford, spent a lifetime educating students about the role of power and how it is exercised through culture to maintain oppressive and exploitative hierarchies that are structured to keep the powerful in power and subordinate all others to their assigned places. This is achieved through the construction of myths or ideologies (not a reference to your political party ideology) that operate to mask, distort, or conceal states of reality. In this process, the reality of domination or exploitation remains hidden in plain sight from those who are being subordinated. To quote one academic, John Storey, “ideology conceals the reality of subordination from those who are powerless: subordinate classes do not see themselves as oppressed or exploited.” Without going much deeper, my point here is that what Jamaicans are here witnessing is the use of cultural power to silence the society’s lesser persons, who some elite members believe have no grounds, or place, to speak. It is an exercise in the use of hegemony, and the power of the state, to silence any opposing or critical ideas, including the very practice and expression of the historical throughline of resistance for which brand Jamaica has become known. Oh, the irony!
Notwithstanding, as a cultural studies scholar, I see a silver lining within the elite clapback that has been meted out in this instance. Among Jamaica’s creative and cultural practitioners, Jamaican musicians are among one of Jamaica’s more powerful political constituencies, with even greater economic power potential. I have made the point in professional circles that Bob Marley stands in Jamaican history as being one of Jamaica’s most powerful individuals, and the circumstances surrounding his attempted assassination in 1976 stand as an example. Again, it was he who united both political leaders in 1978. I suggest here that the power of an organized and economically powerful entertainment class in Jamaica is one that is feared, because they possess national and international influence, media access, and access to finances if they were politically aware of how to utilize that access as a bloc. In effect, the Jamaican entertainment class has the power to reshape the myths and ideologies that dominate the Jamaican society and power structure as we know it, and therefore the utterances of a ‘boy’ from the ghetto, especially if unfavorable to Jamaican power, are not ones that the power structure can afford to ignore. It must therefore be targeted and silenced. This is the larger context in which I would like the current conversation to be understood. Because it is not so much of what is being said, Jamaicans have felt these sentiments about public accountability, and have expressed such all-day every day, but the issue here is who said it (a Jamaican international figure, Beenie Man) and where it is being said (internationally on British ITV News). What we witnessed was Beenie Man’s use of his power precipitating a contest of powers – a very different response from what I expect in relation to this article, because I simply do not have the platform to make such a challenge to authority.
In the 9 November 2026 article, “
Dancehall artistes and the right to free speech” by Nicola Cunningham published in the Gleaner, I made the point that one of the more disturbing aspects of this whole episode to me has been the attack on the institution of democracy, whether directly or indirectly. And I say this because no matter the degree of disagreement, the calling into question of an individual’s right to have an opinion is not in keeping with the historical struggles of the Jamaican people to have sovereignty over their lives, and the ability to make their own decisions as they choose. Even to suggest the dialing back of those hard-won rights among Jamaicans should never be countenanced, and it is a slippery slope if we allow ourselves to go there, as we see too many parts of the world with which we are tightly integrated trend towards various degrees of authoritarianism.
To continue on that throughline that I traced earlier, I wish to emphasize that this exposition is not intended to advocate for the left or the right, the PNP or the JLP, because this conversation is largely one that is about the continued improvement of Jamaican lives. Since the period of enslavement, the people on this island have consistently struggled for sovereignty and dignity, against poverty and exploitation, and exploitative and extractive arrangements, not surprisingly, the antithesis of capitalist exploitative and extractive practice. Having said this, neither is this to be read as an advocacy for socialism, because I think that the Jamaican and Caribbean experience warrants more than a wholly imported paradigm to treat with our challenges, particularly given our layered history of struggle, thought, democratic and economic practices.
Sadly, to my disappointment, there is a failure on the part of both the PNP and the JLP to articulate the economic pain Jamaicans are currently facing, and instead what I see in these spaces is an indulgence in a petty culture war, that is a tit-for-tat game of distraction from the issues that really matter to Jamaicans. Jamaicans, like many others globally, have come fully to the realization that capital has no interest in providing for the public good – health, education, social services, or the environment – if there is no room to make a profit. Going forward, it will be the state that will have to step in; meanwhile, Jamaicans await the arrival of economic democracy into more of its formal spaces, organizations, and politics. In this realm, neither of Jamaica’s political parties shines or is better off, because neither seemingly can move beyond the old social and economic paradigms. There seems to be no awareness of the thinking that now animates some democratic spaces globally around post-growth, wellness, and the social and solidarity economies, and these approaches to addressing poverty and the global polycrisis. Unless the insular, and in some cases elite, lens through which they view the world changes, I suspect that neither will deliver for the ordinary Jamaican because neither has figured out the language, much less a plan to communicate the global economic challenge Jamaica now faces. The reality remains that power will concede nothing without a fight, and if nothing else, Jamaica’s historical throughline, laser-focused on sovereignty, freedom, and democracy, favors the power that rises from below.
Kam-Au Amen is a lecturer in the Institute of Caribbean Studies at the University of the West Indies (UWI), Mona, where he focuses on the growth and management of entertainment and cultural enterprises.